Exclusive Insurance Program for the Automotive Aftermarket Industry

A one-stop insurance solution designed to protect businesses like yours in the automotive aftermarket

Get a Quote

  • Please do not include sensitive, private information in this area.
  • Max. file size: 500 MB.
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Request a Quote
Request a Quote
Request a Quote

Are you struggling to find the right insurance?

As a business owner in the automotive aftermarket industry, you are likely facing these challenges:

  • You have insurance, but it’s not tailored to your unique needs

  • You aren’t sure exactly what coverages you need for your business

  • You’re struggling to find affordable insurance with adequate coverage

  • Your claims experience has been frustrating

  • Your current insurance agent doesn’t understand your industry

Your insurance plan should be tailored to your unique needs and your budget. Work with Garage Guard and you’ll finally get the insurance program your business deserves.


Discover a Proven Plan to Protect Your Business

Get a Quote

High Value Coverage for Your Needs & Your Budget

Jobber Stores

Auto Parts Store Insurance

Auto Repair Garages

Auto Repair Shop Insurance

Workers Compensation

Stand-alone, Pay-as-you-go, workers’ compensation

Garagekeeper’s Insurance

Body & Restoration

Classic Car Auto Dealership

Classic Car Auto Dealership Insurance

Towing Operations Truck Repair Facilities

Commercial Tow Truck Insurance & Truck Repair Garage Insurance

Get a Quote

What the Industry Says About Garage Guard

“I feel confident that I have the correct coverage. In this time of incessant insurance company ads that leave people very confused, having the personal attention of a professional agent makes all the difference!”

“Whenever I have a question or need, I receive an immediate response. Their personalized service is greatly appreciated.”

“Evarts Tremaine is great! Everyone on the team is extremely consultative and provides clients with real insurance that covers us when something goes wrong.”

Get a Quote

Here’s How it Works


Request A Quote


Talk With Insurance Advisor


Secure Right Insurance Plan

Get a Quote
Brian Boland 2022

Brian Boland, CPCU
Director of Garage Guard

Get a Quote

Decades of experience protecting thousands of businesses in the automotive aftermarket with the right insurance solutions.

Since 1998, Garage Guard has provided insurance guidance services for thousands of business owners in the automotive aftermarket.

When you choose Garage Guard, you benefit from decades of industry experience and extensive claims knowledge guiding businesses like yours – because accidents, and life – happen.

You can count on Garage Guard to secure you best value coverage for your needs and your budget.


years serving automotive aftermarket


insured clients


insuring in all states


year average retention


Employee BenefitsGarage Guard®Insurance
June 6, 2024

Voluntary Benefits for the Auto Repair Industry

Attracting and retaining skilled technicians is a major challenge in the auto repair industry, made even more difficult by the…
Garage Guard®Insurance
May 10, 2024

Preventing Vehicle Theft at Your Auto Repair Shop

Vehicle thefts have hit a new record, with over 1 million vehicles stolen nationwide in 2023 according to the National…
Garage Guard®Insurance
March 7, 2024

Navigating Rising Parts Costs in 2024 – Auto Repair Industry

As we navigate through 2024, auto repair shop owners are facing an increasingly common challenge: the rising costs of auto…

About Our Agency

At Evarts Tremaine, our mission is to go above and beyond for our clients, carriers, and our co-workers every day.

From our very first business insurance coverage policies for main street merchants and nascent captains of industry to today’s digital signatures, Clickable Coverages, and cyber crime policies, Evarts Tremaine’s core values remain the same. Integrity, innovation, authenticity, knowledge, teamwork, and fun have been part of our story since the beginning. We are a family of commercial insurance and personal insurance advisors.

Get a Quote

  • Please do not include sensitive, private information in this area.
  • Max. file size: 500 MB.
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

1111 Superior Avenue, Suite 420, Cleveland, OH 44114 | 800-725-4484